L4M4's first learning outcome is about the options for sourcing requirements from suppliers. Before comparing single/dual/multiple sourcing or award criteria, the examiner expects you to be clear on what sourcing is, how it differs from outsourcing and offshoring, and how a make-or-buy decision is reasoned. Aligned to AC 1.1.
1. What sourcing is - strategic vs tactical
Sourcing is a critical activity used at both tactical and strategic levels. It is concerned with what needs to be purchased, why, when and where. Lysons and Farrington describe it as "the process of identifying, selection and development of suppliers."
- Strategic sourcing deals with top-level, longer-term decisions for high-risk strategic and bottleneck items, and with long-term policies on core competences, make-or-buy, the shape of the supplier base, partnership sourcing and ethical issues.
- Tactical and operational sourcing deals with lower-level, short-term, adaptive decisions about how and from where specific requirements are met.
The distinction matters because the examiner often tests whether a given decision (e.g. choosing a single partner for a critical sub-assembly) is strategic or merely operational - the answer drives who decides and how much analysis is justified.
2. Outsourcing, offshoring and nearshoring (AC 1.1)
Outsourcing is "the process of contracting with the most suitable expert third party service provider" (CIPS). It is the operational transfer of one or more business processes to an external provider who becomes accountable for the agreed tasks. Two terms are routinely confused with it and with each other:
- Outsourcing always requires a third party.
- Offshoring (moving work to a foreign, usually low-cost, country) does not necessarily involve a third party - it can be internal to the firm (a captive overseas operation).
- Nearshoring is work transferred to a nearby country.
So an organisation can offshore without outsourcing (its own overseas plant) and outsource without offshoring (a domestic third-party provider).
3. Make-or-buy decisions (AC 1.1)
Key factors when deciding whether to make/do in-house or buy in include:
- Whether the item is strategically important or core to the business
- The relative cost of making in-house versus buying in
- Differences in quality or timescales
- Availability of in-house competencies and capacity
- Availability of capable external suppliers
- Risks of sub-contracting (loss of control, in-house knowledge, confidential information and IP)
- Human-resource impacts (redundancies, or recruitment and training costs)
- Opportunity cost of using in-house capacity on this rather than on something else
- Potential CSR issues of using suppliers with poor labour records
Core competencies (Prahalad and Hamel) are central corporate skills, based on knowledge and experience, that distinguish a company and give long-term competitive advantage. The decision rule the examiner rewards: keep core, distinctive activities in-house; outsource non-critical work to capable suppliers.
4. Supplier appraisal terms - keep them apart
The module distinguishes three stages that students frequently merge:
- Pre-qualification / appraisal - evaluates potential bidders before tenders are invited, against criteria, so only those meeting defined standards may bid (reducing procurement cycle time). It is a backward-looking examination of a supplier's general suitability and capability.
- Vendor rating - assessment of a supplier's performance after the contract is awarded.
- Supplier development - working with a supplier to raise its capability over time.