Skip to main content

Types of Approach in Commercial Negotiation

Free Preview

The three main approaches to commercial negotiation are collaborative (win-win/integrative - expanding the pie, focus on interests, high information sharing, creative solutions, long-term relationship), distributive (win-lose/zero-sum - fixed pie, focus on positions, low information sharing, binary outcomes, short-term relationship), and principled (a structured codification of win-win based on four fundamentals: people, interests, options, objective criteria). BATNA and ZOPA are the tools for knowing when to negotiate and when to walk away.

AC 1.2 requires you to differentiate the main approaches to commercial negotiation. The examiner will present scenarios and expect you to identify the correct approach - and justify why. The three main approaches are collaborative (win-win/integrative), distributive (win-lose/zero-sum), and principled. Aligned to AC 1.2.

1. Collaborative - win-win (integrative) approach

The collaborative approach is described as an integrative approach in which the 'pie' can be expanded and shared so that both parties benefit. Rather than assuming a fixed resource to divide, both parties work to create value that can then be split.

Key characteristics:

  • Negotiation focus: interests - parties move away from stated positions as quickly as possible to surface the underlying interests that drive those positions.
  • High information sharing - both parties share more data to identify joint-gain opportunities.
  • Multiple issues discussed simultaneously - all issues are put on the table at once, enabling trades across variables.
  • Solution sought: performance-based - creative solutions satisfactory to both parties, not just conformance to a fixed specification.
  • Relationship: long-term / regular engagement - the approach suits partners with whom an ongoing relationship is valued.
  • More co-operative; both parties are satisfied with the outcome, even if neither gets 100% of what they wanted.

This is described as the best approach to achieve objectives when the relationship matters and there is scope for joint value creation.

2. Distributive - win-lose (zero-sum) approach

The distributive approach is sometimes called bargaining or the zero-sum approach. One party's gain is the other's loss - the 'pie' is assumed fixed.

Key characteristics:

  • Negotiation focus: positions - parties keep their interests confidential because revealing them may expose weakness; positions are defended or traded.
  • Low information sharing - 'need to know' only; confidentiality is maintained.
  • One issue at a time - issues are negotiated sequentially rather than packaged.
  • Solution sought: conformance-based - binary yes/no outcomes (accept or reject).
  • Relationship: short-term / once-off - used when the relationship with the other party is not important or where this is a one-time purchase.
  • Parties are described as adversaries; the approach is called 'claiming value'.
  • This is described as the most honest approach in the sense that positions are clear, even though it is competitive.

Examples of win-lose situations:

  • Property and land deals where you must outbid other buyers
  • Purchases where price is the only variable
  • Trade union negotiations
  • Government budget distribution

Comparison of approaches:

FeatureCollaborative (win-win)Distributive (win-lose)
FocusInterestsPositions
Information sharingHighLow (need-to-know)
IssuesMultiple at onceOne at a time
SolutionPerformance / creativeConformance / binary
RelationshipLong-termShort-term / once-off
Value assumptionPie can expandPie is fixed

Sign up free to read the rest

Sign up free

Already have an account? Sign in