AC 1.2 requires you to differentiate the main approaches to commercial negotiation. The examiner will present scenarios and expect you to identify the correct approach - and justify why. The three main approaches are collaborative (win-win/integrative), distributive (win-lose/zero-sum), and principled. Aligned to AC 1.2.
1. Collaborative - win-win (integrative) approach
The collaborative approach is described as an integrative approach in which the 'pie' can be expanded and shared so that both parties benefit. Rather than assuming a fixed resource to divide, both parties work to create value that can then be split.
Key characteristics:
- Negotiation focus: interests - parties move away from stated positions as quickly as possible to surface the underlying interests that drive those positions.
- High information sharing - both parties share more data to identify joint-gain opportunities.
- Multiple issues discussed simultaneously - all issues are put on the table at once, enabling trades across variables.
- Solution sought: performance-based - creative solutions satisfactory to both parties, not just conformance to a fixed specification.
- Relationship: long-term / regular engagement - the approach suits partners with whom an ongoing relationship is valued.
- More co-operative; both parties are satisfied with the outcome, even if neither gets 100% of what they wanted.
This is described as the best approach to achieve objectives when the relationship matters and there is scope for joint value creation.
2. Distributive - win-lose (zero-sum) approach
The distributive approach is sometimes called bargaining or the zero-sum approach. One party's gain is the other's loss - the 'pie' is assumed fixed.
Key characteristics:
- Negotiation focus: positions - parties keep their interests confidential because revealing them may expose weakness; positions are defended or traded.
- Low information sharing - 'need to know' only; confidentiality is maintained.
- One issue at a time - issues are negotiated sequentially rather than packaged.
- Solution sought: conformance-based - binary yes/no outcomes (accept or reject).
- Relationship: short-term / once-off - used when the relationship with the other party is not important or where this is a one-time purchase.
- Parties are described as adversaries; the approach is called 'claiming value'.
- This is described as the most honest approach in the sense that positions are clear, even though it is competitive.
Examples of win-lose situations:
- Property and land deals where you must outbid other buyers
- Purchases where price is the only variable
- Trade union negotiations
- Government budget distribution
Comparison of approaches:
| Feature | Collaborative (win-win) | Distributive (win-lose) |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Interests | Positions |
| Information sharing | High | Low (need-to-know) |
| Issues | Multiple at once | One at a time |
| Solution | Performance / creative | Conformance / binary |
| Relationship | Long-term | Short-term / once-off |
| Value assumption | Pie can expand | Pie is fixed |