Portfolio Analysis Techniques for Supply Chain Relationships
Portfolio analysis identifies where to focus procurement effort, what relationship to build with each supplier, and where vulnerability lies. Three techniques work together: supply positioning (Kraljic), supplier preferencing, and the market management matrix. AC 1.2.
Pareto and ABC - context, not portfolio
The Pareto principle (80/20) holds that roughly 80% of spend sits with 20% of suppliers. ABC analysis applies the same logic: A items ≈ 80% of cost and 20% of volume; B items in the middle; C items are low-cost, high-volume. Useful for directing effort, but ABC does not consider supply risk or strategic impact, gives no relationship recommendation, and is not a portfolio technique - treat it as prioritisation context only.
The Kraljic model (supply positioning)
Maps purchases against financial/profit impact (vertical) × supply risk (horizontal), and underpins category management.
| Quadrant | Position | Typical strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Routine | Low risk / low value (e.g. MRO, stationery) | Procurement cards, reverse auctions, call-off contracts; arm's-length, transactional |
| Bottleneck | High risk / low value (e.g. OEM parts, computer chips) | Few suppliers, limited availability; long-term contracts, buffer stock, seek alternatives |
| Leverage | Low risk / high value | Competitive tendering, target pricing, consortia procurement |
| Strategic | High risk / high value | Long-term partnership, balanced power, strategic alliance, co-destiny |
Supply risk arises from (1) individual supplier failure - quality, delivery, price - or (2) market characteristics such as few suppliers or volatile demand (Zsidisin, 2003). Risk can be internal or external - the STEEPLE factors on the competitive-forces page describe external supply-risk drivers. A common formula: Total risk = Likelihood × Impact.
Benefits: simple, applicable to all industries, clarifies item importance, guides relationship choice. Limitations: subjective; only a snapshot; applies to products and services, not the supplier itself; limited academic foundation.
Exam trap: financial impact is always the vertical axis, supply risk always horizontal - flip them and every quadrant's placement and strategy changes.
Supplier preferencing model
Shows how the supplier views the buyer. Axes: account attractiveness - profitability, growth, contract stability, ethics, and willingness to collaborate - (vertical) × relative value of the business to the supplier (horizontal).
| Quadrant | What it signals | Buyer response |
|---|---|---|
| Core (high attractiveness / high value) | Supplier's priority account; best service level | Cosset; defend vigorously |
| Development (high attractiveness / low value) | Supplier wants to grow the account | Reward with additional business to move toward Core |
| Nuisance (low / low) | Supplier indifferent; may de-prioritise or withdraw | Try to increase the account's attractiveness to move it toward Development |
| Exploitable (low attractiveness / high value) | Supplier extracts a premium; short-term view | Find business the supplier would find attractive to pull it toward Core |
Advantage: reveals information the buyer may not have. Limitation: snapshot based on the buyer's judgement.