Skip to main content

Types of Commercial Relationships in Supply Chains

Free Preview

SRM identifies and manages interactions with key suppliers to grow value for both parties by selecting the most beneficial relationship type for each requirement. Supply is internal (in-house, core, greater control but fixed+variable cost) or external (independent, often expert and cost-effective but raising dependency risk). The relationship spectrum runs from competitive/tactical (adversarial, arm's-length, transactional) through closer-tactical, single-source and outsourced to collaborative/strategic (strategic alliance, partnership, co-destiny), with duration, trust, communication and innovation rising together. Relationships pass through a life cycle (on-boarding to phase-out), with qualification supported by RFI/RFP and Carter's 10 Cs, and conflict resolved win-lose, lose-lose or win-win.

Types of Commercial Relationships in Supply Chains

SRM (Supplier Relationship Management) is the process of identifying all interactions with key suppliers and managing them so that value increases for both parties. AC 1.1. There is no single "best" relationship type - the right choice depends on the category, risk profile, and market conditions.


Internal vs external supply

The first choice is whether to make or buy.

Internal supply (in-house) typically produces core products or services and is governed by the make-or-buy decision.

  • Advantages: greater control, continuity of supply, quality oversight, lower cost (no supplier margin), protected IP.
  • Disadvantages: no competitive pressure to improve unless benchmarked; the organisation carries fixed and variable costs (an external supplier carries only variable cost); investment carries an opportunity cost. Internal supply may not work where volumes are too low, licences or permits are required, or key skills are scarce.

External supply (independent supplier) brings market expertise and scale. Selection weighs purchase price, delivery lead time, quality and experience; risks to evaluate include insolvency, delays, natural disasters, human-rights issues and political instability.

  • Advantages: specialist knowledge, economies of scale, frees internal resources, flexibility to demand swings.
  • Disadvantages: dependency risk (insolvency, disruption, political instability), reputational risk from unethical supplier behaviour, transport and management cost.

The relationship spectrum

The spectrum classifies the relationship currently in place, running from competitive/tactical (left) to collaborative/strategic (right). Moving right, trust, duration, communication depth, and innovation all increase together.

TypeCharacter
AdversarialDeal outcome over relationship; non-core or one-off; low trust, short-term contracts
Arm's-lengthInfrequent; parties act independently, exploiting market pricing
TransactionalHigher frequency/volume; low value, low risk; competitive tendering viable
Closer tacticalCompetent supplier needed but full collaboration not commercially justified
Single-sourceOne chosen supplier for commercial benefit (e.g. volume discounts); top-management decision; high trust and dependence
OutsourcedIn-house activity moved out for cost or capability reasons; TUPE applies to transferring staff
Strategic allianceIndependent organisations pursue agreed objectives, each retaining a separate legal identity
PartnershipHigh-risk/high-value; long-term; broadly equal power; focus on innovation and quality improvement
Co-destinyDeep interdependence; buyer and supplier make decisions jointly; the most collaborative position

Exam trap: the spectrum classifies the current relationship, not the ideal one. Exam questions often describe a scenario and ask where it sits on the spectrum, or what change is needed and why. Know what drives movement right (greater trust, longer duration, deeper communication, joint innovation) versus what justifies staying left (low risk, low value, plentiful alternatives).


The relationship life cycle

Relationships evolve through stages: on-boarding → qualification → segmentation → risk management → performance management → development and innovation → phase-out (if required).

At qualification, buyers use RFI/RFP and may apply Carter's 10 Cs: Competency, Capacity, Commitment to quality, Control of processes, Cash, Cost, Consistency, Culture, Clean, Communication. Thorough, but time- and resource-intensive for both parties.

Sign up free to read the rest

Sign up free

Already have an account? Sign in